Match conflicts List


Conflict
Massive monsters players used cheats
by hornyz (mTw), submitted on 23 Nov 18:48:

"Dear admins, we played mM (massive Monsters) in a cb war. Befor during and after the war we had the suspision that mM players used erd party tools. Like codehook x22 or something similar. This team comes from nowhere and beat everybody in clanbase.

It was strange timing, prefireing unbelievable reactions, pms from former teammates, matchcomments. That supported the feeling that massive monsters uses hax. Well we are one of the best teams in europe and have np losing against teams which are clearly better but not versus cheaters.

I made a timetable from 2 of their players which seemed to be the most obvious ones. s4nzje and tracy. I did not have the time to analyze the other players and this is my first timetable in clanbase. so please forgive me if not everything is easy to read and understandable.

Starting with s4anzj3 on crossfire only
looking on his account he got various reasons to play with different guids. Started playing somewhere in 2010 according to his profile. According to other protests he uses guids from banned players.

Well thats just some facts besides the war:
1 Round: 1:16 instant reaction 2 deaglehits
3 Round 1:33 looking on models through smoke?
4 Round 1:10 looking a alley, looking back street, suddenly turning fast back probably opponent coming? funny
5 Round 1:35 Smoke but he looks on the model?
1:10 he looks on model through wall and shoots with deagle
6 Round why look up spawnhouse now? seeing model there directly on the model preaim through wall
7 Round 1:33 - 1:30 knows both players position? unlucky thunder got better reactions.
9 Round 1:35 aiming on a just before player jumps he goes down with crosshair?
10 Round 1:24 very fast shooting on plotsch even though there is smoke? Knowledge? Cause he is flashed !
11 Round 1:35 smoke on street aims on hitbox and 1:32 aims on topspawnhouse instantly on the model, smoke on the street
waiting on kebap player 1:10 - 0.50 surprise nice timing when opponent appears he is looking right
0:40 looking right on me, could be luck
0:37 prefireing jetleck and hits?
13 Round watching a Bottom at 1:23 perfect timing shoting player (orefire)
1:10 follow model through wall
14 Round looking a Bottom instantly at 1:27 on the wall oh look there is opponent still behind
16 Round watching with scope there? Smoke lying there scope useless, sees model bottom a watching there unscoped, scoped unscope. when thunder comes he got perfect timing again.
17 Round prefireing, why suddenly doing crouch behind car? watching with hax?
0:16 Seconds on the model through car.
18 Round prefiring 1:35 spraying on hitboxes?
0:45 just looking same spot? even though nobody watches street. could come from bottom a? why does he know that. Surprise againg perfect timing from him? killing plotsch.
19 Round1:15- 1:08 just looking same spot? even though nobody watches street. could come from bottom a? why does he know that. Surprise againg perfect timing from him? killing plotsch.
1:00 following models through wall, when model goes back he goes back when he comes he looks.
0:40 leaning until he sees me??? seriously
0:25 -0:20 on the model ups there is a wall
20 Round seems to know he is coming 1:35 ups next coming too prefireing at 1:22 but plotsch faster.
22 Round 1:35 smoke prefiring hitboxes
23: 1:33 on the model aiming oh shit smoke i shouldnt shoot :P ???
1:27 on model ups smoke but kills

Tracy: Crossfire and backlot (only one scene)
Round 1 1:35 why go back, maybe opponent behind him?
Round 2 1:31 ESP hack?

*Round 5 0:54 why look there??? instanly

Round 6 1:35 why look against wall?
1:23 why look so?
1:18 wow nice reactions :P
0:34 why not go to the spot?
0:32 perfect timing and wow nice reactions again
Round 7 0:52 height of weapon... on the model?
Round 8 1:10 wall? prefire could be okay under normal circumstances

*Round 11 1:25 - 0:54 not even covering himself, seriously you would never watch like that only you can be 100 percent sure, nobody would come there. Then perfect timing aiming on models through wall, shooting thunder on street. Obviously hacking

Round 12 1:15 on model through wall
0:55 goes back when opponent coming :P
0:45 prefire
0:38 on model through wall
0:30 shoot at corps maybe saw the opponent in the corner :P
Titto got best reactions and kills opponent instantly :P at 0:29

Round 13 1:23 hard prefiring through wall on model :P
Round 14 1:33 on model through smoke and flashed and wall jumping out as if he knows where 2 opponents are :P
Round 15 0:15 on the model through wall, why look up on the model at 0:09 and killing instantly :P
Round 16 funny mouse shacking at the begining 1:40 some hax are used with mouse shacking :P
Round 18 1:27 crosshair stops on model for a moment?
Round 20 prefiring street, models smoke @ 1:33
1:20-1:15 look on wall?
Round 22 1:27 right timing in walkthrough???
Round 23 1:25 mouse shacking ???
1:10 normally look somewhere else first? :P but now on player

Backlot:
why does tracy look every round at the beginning at the big house as defender? can he look through and tell where the opponent comes from???
Round 1 Titto 1:10 on model through wall? who looks like that? nobody going in a?
0:52 titto looking again on model through walls
Round 2 tracy nice reactions 1:13
0:34 - 0:24 and why aiming so low?
Round 5 nice jump at 1:10 instantly on the model? and hits :P
Round 6: 0:24 on the model through wall and shoot?
0:20 prefire is okay but that one is ridiculous.

in my opinion this is enough."
What we've done to solve the conflict ourselves:
"We asked for their demos and received them."
Claim: "mM players should be banned from CB for C&A"
Match
Match between mTw more and mM more 21 Nov 18:30.
Ladder: CoD4 Search & Destroy Europe rules
mTw won from mM.
Forfeit win.
Matchrules:
  • Maxrounds: Maxrounds 12
  • Decision
    "The demos came back from demo crew with verdict NOT CLEAN
    therefore they are both now banned.

    If you think your ban was not justified, then fill in this from to appeal your ban,

    Appeals

    If anyone feels their ban is unjustified, they are free to use the
    ClanBase appeal process. To do so please email us (cheatappeals@clanbase.com) with all relevant information including:

    * Nick
    * Game Type
    * Offence
    * IP
    * AntiCheat who made the original catch.
    * countertimestamps

    Anyone who fails to appeal within 3 months of the original ban, will forfeit their right to the appeal process. Appeals will be handled by the ClanBase Cheat & Abuse crew and can take up to 1 month depending on the case.

    Forfeit loss given to mM

    Case Closed
    Denno"

    by Denno, December 25th 2010